Why On Earth Would You Ever Want to Learn French?

A couple of weeks ago, I retweeted an awesome article about the presence of the French language in New York City’s bilingual schools. In a globalized society, dual language learning has never been more important (although world languages are also facing some big cuts throughout public schools.)

Fast forward a few days later, and New Republic’s John McWhorter comes out with a response article, entitled, Let’s Stop pretending French is an Important Language. His narrow-minded viewpoint simply implies that the only importance of learning a language is for career advancement, and the only important languages to use are Spanish and Chinese, and perhaps Arabic. According to Mr. McWhorter, French is simply not useful so therefore it is simply a waste of time to learn.

Flashback to my undergraduate career, I strayed away from French because I was told I would, “never get a job.” Up on returning from Normandy, however, I quickly said, “Screw that!” and quickly changed my major to French Education. Unfortunately, this change did not come without several degrading comments from various university professors in regards to my choosing French over Spanish (very encouraging that Education Professors would be discouraging education students from obtaining certain certifications!) In response, after graduating I published an article on A Woman’s Paris entitled, Why on Earth Would You Ever Want to Teach French?

What infuriates me most about John McWhorter’s article is not ONLY that he refers to French as useless but that he– A LINGUIST– believes that the only sole benefits to language learning is for potential employment. As a French teacher from a country with NO OFFICIAL LANGUAGE, and where a Coca Cola commercial representing America in multiple languages is seen as “controversial,” instead of beautiful, and where language-fluency is seen as low priority or a waste of time (because everyone speaks English and should learn English, right?), it’s disheartening. It’s equally unfortunate that public schools are pushing Common Core’s Global Citizenship yet continue to cut world languages from the curriculum, as well as rank some languages as more important than others. It’s unfortunate to see well-known, influential politicians write articles such as this one.

Of course, language competency is important and it can certainly play a huge factor in potential employment (my studies and travels, international internship, and knowledge of French certainly helped me land my first teaching job.) However, I wish McWhorter would consider that being competent in multiple languages may be beneficial for reasons other than employment, or that it is almost a personal responsibility as a global citizen to learn multiple languages.

French is spoken on six continents of the world, including Canada, half of Africa, the Middle East, and yes, Western Europe. France is the number one tourist destination in the world, and the official language of the Olympic Games. It is also the third most-used language on the internet. Learning French makes learning other Romance languages easier, including Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Romanian, in addition to the English language, as 50 percent of English words are derived from French. The French language is found in various domains, such as architecture, cooking, fashion, theatre, and dance.

I chose to learn French because I love the language and it’s overall cultural influences on our world. Becoming (almost) fluent has immensely expanded my vocabulary and understanding of languages in general. I am able to express myself in two different languages and because of my knowledge of French, my comprehension English phonetics and grammar has also improved. Traveling in Barcelona, I seldom used my English, but got by with Catalan-speakers thanks to my knowledge of French (I suspect it will be similar in Morocco.) Living in a French-speaking country has also helped me to become a better, more empathetic teacher with my ELL students living in an English-speaking country. Learning French has helped me to better understand other cultures and make connections to my own. Finally, knowing French is what helped me to successfully move and work abroad.

I never want to discourage anyone from learning any language. If you have a strong desire to learn Spanish or Chinese, learn Spanish or Chinese. If you want to learn Scandinavian languages, African languages, or Native American languages, do it! And, if you want to learn French, learn French. But do it because you want to, because you’re inspired, because your feel a connection to the culture, because you want to live or work with this language. Do it because, as Nika Likes Maps (whom I discovered from A French American Life) points out, “Learning a language is an access card to seeing life through another perspective.”

All of the languages on the world are individual puzzle pieces which make up a larger puzzle. One is not more important than the other, for without all of the pieces in the puzzle we would not have a complete masterpiece.



References: http://www.consulfrance-houston.org/spip.php?article1426

8 thoughts on “Why On Earth Would You Ever Want to Learn French?

  1. I like your take on this one. It’s is sad to hear a noted linguist make a justification on learning languages based on job prospects. This is what make intellectual life in America dull. It’s all money money money. I live in America now, but I am a Thai. I speak Thai as my native language and my English is pretty OK. I speak English fluently and went to a US law school. I can also speak a bit of Japaneseand Chinese. Chinese is a language that is structurally close to Thai, and, contrary to what people in the west believe, it’s pretty easy to learn conversational Chinese. Chinese, however, is not very fashionable back home in Thailand since a lot of Thais can speak chinese (even I is half Thai-Chinese ethincally).

    1. Did not you move to the United States to have a better quality of life? So, do not want to criticize “Everything is for money” You criticize the American mentality, but you live there for better opportunities.

  2. As I love to remind people, I got my job because I speak French and it’s not a teaching job. It is definitely a useful language, especially in the arts (which is the field I sort of work in). I did go on to major in Spanish and got my MA in in and lived in Spain for two years post-college. But so far, French has trumped Spanish in my (very short) career. I may be an exception and not the norm, I have no idea.

    But I think everybody should learn whatever language they please. It’s a free country. 🙂

    1. Exactly! I hate when people dismiss French as not useful. I’m not at all saying that people shouldn’t learn Chinese or Spanish, because these are without a doubt key influential, and important languages! But if someone wants to learn German or Italian or Icelandic or Thai or Welsh, or whatever, I do not think they should be denied the resources just because some people see the language as “not useful.” You never know where you’ll end up in the future! 🙂

  3. Yes!!!! Creating a hierarchy of “useful” languages is attributing a false sense of “worthiness” or value to different cultures. The fact is, learning another language – ANY language, is good for your brain and good for broadening your horizons. On a related note, I love this adage: “A language is just a dialect with an army and a navy.” Love this post!

Let me know what you think!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.